
Hmmm. What to say about wikis?
I like the democratic aspect of them, the notion of collective knowledge, contributed and built on by many. People with particular interests contribute their expertise, and the quality of entries is determined by peer editing, so blatant errors and misinformation are (mostly) weeded out. It’s a nice idea. Yes, we all know of instances where people pre-eminent in their field have contributed detailed, thoughtful and lengthy entries, only to have them edited and overwritten the next day by an entry full of errors and outdated information, but that’s how democracies work. And by and large, I think wikis work well.
The down side of wikis is they are a collaborative effort, so they really need to have a number of contributors to work effectively. Despite the number of readers, if only one or two people ever contribute, are they still a wiki? Or are they just a bulletin board with a Hawaiian name?
They also need to be current to maintain relevance, and I think that this comes back to the number of contributors. Once you reach a “critical mass” of enthusiastic authors, they seem to gather momentum and take on a life of their own. But too few authors, and the posts get fewer and further apart, and they eventually run out of steam. I suppose it’s democracy again, people will vote for the ones they like.
The lesson for libraries is that wikis are a great tool for encouraging interaction with patrons and can work really well, but they need to be kept up to date and relevant by a group of enthusiastic people. An vibrant wiki community is a wonderful thing, but a sad and tired wiki makes your library appear, well ...sad and tired.
I like the democratic aspect of them, the notion of collective knowledge, contributed and built on by many. People with particular interests contribute their expertise, and the quality of entries is determined by peer editing, so blatant errors and misinformation are (mostly) weeded out. It’s a nice idea. Yes, we all know of instances where people pre-eminent in their field have contributed detailed, thoughtful and lengthy entries, only to have them edited and overwritten the next day by an entry full of errors and outdated information, but that’s how democracies work. And by and large, I think wikis work well.
The down side of wikis is they are a collaborative effort, so they really need to have a number of contributors to work effectively. Despite the number of readers, if only one or two people ever contribute, are they still a wiki? Or are they just a bulletin board with a Hawaiian name?
They also need to be current to maintain relevance, and I think that this comes back to the number of contributors. Once you reach a “critical mass” of enthusiastic authors, they seem to gather momentum and take on a life of their own. But too few authors, and the posts get fewer and further apart, and they eventually run out of steam. I suppose it’s democracy again, people will vote for the ones they like.
The lesson for libraries is that wikis are a great tool for encouraging interaction with patrons and can work really well, but they need to be kept up to date and relevant by a group of enthusiastic people. An vibrant wiki community is a wonderful thing, but a sad and tired wiki makes your library appear, well ...sad and tired.

No comments:
Post a Comment